The 8th Virginia Regiment
  • Home
  • Blog
  • The Regiment
  • The Soldiers
  • Family
  • Living History
  • Learn More
  • Contact

Catholics and the Founding

6/28/2022

1 Comment

 
Picture
Our Dear-Bought Liberty: Catholics and Religious Toleration in Early America
Michael D. Breidenbach (Harvard University Press, 2021)
Most Americans in pre-revolutionary times had a strong dislike of Catholicism. They believed it to be a religion of ignorance, a religion of tyranny, and the religion of the enemy. The ever-opinionated John Adams attended a mass in Philadelphia in 1774, motivated by “curiosity and good company.” He wrote home to Abigail to describe the “poor Wretches, fingering their Beads, chanting Latin, not a Word of which they understood, their Pater Nosters and Ave Maria’s. Their holy Water—their Crossing themselves perpetually—their Bowing to the Name of Jesus, wherever they hear it—their Bowings, and Kneelings, and Genuflections before the Altar.” 
He described the priest’s ornate vestments, the beautiful music, and the bloody crucifix above the altar. “Here is every Thing which can lay hold of the Eye, Ear, and Imagination. Every Thing which can charm and bewitch the simple and ignorant. I wonder how Luther ever broke the spell.” He admitted, though, that the sermon was good.

​
Protestants’ views of Catholics aside, it was the Church itself, and more specifically the Papacy, that presented a problem for the British Empire. The influential political thinker John Locke asserted in his 1689 Letter Concerning Toleration that a “church can have no right to be tolerated by the magistrate, which is constituted upon such a bottom, that all those who enter into it . . . deliver themselves up to the protection and service of another prince.”[3] By tolerating such a church, a ruler would “suffer his own people, to be lifted, as it were, for soldiers against his own government.”[4] The example he used was Islam, but it was Catholicism he was concerned about.

​Michael Breidenbach is a Cambridge University-educated associate history professor at Ave Maria University, an orthodox Catholic school in Florida. His book Our Dear-Bought Liberty: Catholics and Religious Toleration in Early America illustrates the remarkably rapid transformation of Americans’ treatment of Catholics during the Founding Era. Irish Catholics like Capt. John Barry, Lt. Col. John Fitzgerald, and Col. Stephen Moylan played important roles in the Continental Navy and Army. Maryland’s Charles Carroll signed the Declaration of Independence and held a seat on the Continental Congress’s powerful Board of War. Generals Lafayette and Pulaski were both Catholic, as were the French and Spanish empires that came to America’s aid.
Picture

More from The 8th Virginia Regiment

Picture
Picture
Picture
1 Comment

The “Grand Division Standard” of the 8th Va.

6/20/2022

1 Comment

 
Picture
Rob Andrews and Erik Dorman guard an 8th Virginia division standard in front of the Shenandoah County Courthouse in Woodstock, Virginia in 2012. (Courtesy of Rob Andrews)
Authentic Revolutionary War-era flags are incredibly rare artifacts, and the ones that survive are sometimes misunderstood. A case in point is a flag associated with the 8th Virginia that is privately owned but currently on public display.
 
Regimental flags were not just symbols—they were, like fifes and drums, used for command and control on the battlefield. Noise, confusion, and black-powder smoke could make it hard for individual soldiers to know what they were supposed to be doing. Failure to stay in formation could quickly lead to a loss on the battlefield. Large, waving, colorful flags helped prevent that from happening.
While the Grand Union flag and the Stars and Stripes may have appeared on some battlefields, they were more likely to be seen on forts and ships. Virginia had no state flag until the Civil War. Every regiment, however, had a flag that served important symbolic and battlefield purposes. Regimental flags were unique works of art, often featuring symbols from antiquity or popular culture with mottos in English or Latin. The flags of the 1st Pennsylvania Regiment and Connecticut’s 2nd Continental Light Dragoons are among the very few that survive.

​There is, however, an 8th Virginia flag that still exists—but it is not the regimental banner. It is a “grand division standard,” one of two that were used to direct halves of the regiment on the battlefield. These were utilitarian devices with little ornamentation. The most important thing about them was their color. 
The surviving 8th Virginia division standard was hidden from public view for 150 years. “The first time I heard of the 8th Virginia Standard was during an internet search on the 8th,” reported Rob Andrews, an SAR member and Revolutionary War reenactor with the 1st Virginia Regiment in 2015. What he found was an 1847 reference in the Richmond Whig.  The newspaper quoted Peter Muhlenberg’s great nephew saying, “The regimental color of this corps (8th Virginia Regiment of the Line) is still in the [my] possession.  It is made of plain salmon-colored silk, with a broad fringe of the same, having a simple white scroll in the centre, upon which are inscribed the words, ‘VIII Virga. Reg’t.’ The spear-head is brass, considerably ornamented.  The banner bears the traces of warm service, and is probably the only revolutionary flag in existence.”
Picture
A close-up of the flag's fringe also shows the netting that is used conserve the flag. (Author)
Henry A. Muhlenberg was at that time preparing to publish a biography of his great uncle, the still-useful (but occasionally inaccurate) Life of Major-General Peter Muhlenberg of the Revolutionary Army. The younger Muhlenberg was a member of Congress and quite knowledgeable about his pedigree, but his description of the flag as “the regimental color” was wrong.
Picture
The repainted side of the flag as displayed by Bernard Goetz before 2012. Exposure to light resulted in a rectangle of faded fabric in the center of both sides of the flag. (B. Goetz, courtesy of R. Andrews)
Other than the 1847 reference, Rob could find no mention of the flag anywhere. “I emailed the folks at Valley Forge and the Trappe Foundation in Trappe PA, where the Muhlenberg family lived.  Emails bounced around and finally one person said he thought he knew who had it. I didn't hear anything for a while and then one day an email from Bernard Goetz popped into my box with two pictures of the flag.  It was in a frame and had a card at the bottom stating its provenance.  I was appalled at the pictures and immediately advised Mr Goetz to remove the flag from the frame.” The flag had not been professionally conserved, had faded where it faced the glass, and was displayed with a card that claimed a service history that followed General Muhlenberg’s career, but not that of the 8th Virginia (which he led for just a year).
“That was all I heard of it for several years,” Rob reported.

​Sometime later, “Mr. Goetz passed away and [in 2012] his descendants placed all his historical artifacts up for auction at Freeman’s Auction in Philadelphia. Prior to the auction, Freeman’s brought it to Shenandoah County to be displayed.  I was lucky that I found out about it just a couple of days prior to the event.  I contacted my friend Erik [Dorman] who also was interested in writing about the 8th and we decided to show up in our uniforms.  We caused quite a stir when we walked around the corner of the Courthouse into the square.  We were immediately enlisted to "guard" the flag and unveil it during the event.”
Rob also shared one important explanation about the flag’s appearance. “As someone in the past painted the flag so that 8th Virginia was visible” the opposite side of the flag is displayed “to show its original condition.  And its years in the frame have led to its faded rectangle appearance.” The flag was purchased anonymously and is once again owned by a private collector. It was briefly displayed again at the Winterthur Museum in Delaware and is presently on display again in Philadelphia.

​The Muhlenburg flag resurfaced six years after another set of Virginia flags reappeared. The flag of the 3rd Virginia “detachment” was put up for auction in 2006 by a descendent of Banastre Tarlton. It is probably the only surviving Virginia regimental flag and is reportedly the oldest existing 13-star flag. It features a beaver (America) felling a tree (the empire) and the motto Perseverando (“By persevering”) in Latin.
Picture
The "3rd Virginia Detachment" banner captured by Banastre Tarlton in 1780.
With it were two smaller, plainer flags of identical design but different colors. The 3rd Detachment was an ad hoc unit cobbled together under Col. Abraham Buford in 1780 from new recruits and soldiers who had avoided capture at Charleston earlier that year. The flags were used at the Waxhaws in South Carolina on May 29 when Tarlton defeated Buford there. It is unlikely that the flags were made specifically for the detachment. The regimental flag is described in detail in a 1778 inventory of then-new flags known as the “Gostelowe Return.” The flags were probably, therefore, inherited from a regiment that was folded into Buford’s detachment. Buford had been colonel of the 11th Virginia, and a number of the men in his detachment were reportedly from the 2nd Virginia. The flag could have come from either of those, or from another.
Picture
Picture
Picture
The two “grand division” flags from the Buford detachment are almost identical, except for their colors, to the Muhlenberg flag. Buford’s maneuvering flags are blue and yellow. The Muhlenberg flag is a beige color today and was described as a “salmon” color in 1847. A fabric expert advises that the original color was red. The flag has faded considerably just from its time in the frame. It is not hard to imagine it having faded from red to a salmon color over the century or so before it was framed by Mr. Goetz.

​The scrolls on the blue and yellow flags contain only the word "regiment." The word is not centered in the scroll, suggesting that a space was retained to the left  on both flags to be filled in when they were assigned to a specific regiment. The writing in the 8th Virginia's scroll is illegible now. It was retouched on one side by Mr. Goetz or a previous owner to say "VIII Virg Regt." The 1847 account in the Richmond Whig says the scroll was styled a bit differently as "VIII Virga Regt."
Picture
The grand division standard as it likely appeared when new, recreated by 8th Virginia Regiment reenactor Nathan Gibson. (Courtesy of Nathan Gibson)
A comparison of this flag to other Virginia standards could not be done until after it and the Buford flags had all resurfaced. Now that a comparison is possible, it is quite clear that the Muhlenberg flag was in fact one of two divisional standards. Though a maneuvering banner and not the regimental standard, the flag is still a treasure. It is presently on display at the Museum of the American Revolution in Philadelphia.

More from The 8th Virginia Regiment

Picture
Picture
Picture
1 Comment
    Picture

    Gabriel Neville

    is researching the history of the Revolutionary War's 8th Virginia Regiment. Its ten companies formed on the frontier, from the Cumberland Gap to Pittsburgh.

    Categories

    All
    Artifacts & Memorials
    Book Reviews
    Brandywine & Germantown
    Charleston & Sunbury
    Disease
    Frontier
    Generals
    Organization
    Other Revolutionary War
    Race
    Religion
    Trenton & Princeton
    Valley Forge & Monmouth
    Veterans

    Archives

    February 2023
    January 2023
    November 2022
    August 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    October 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    April 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    November 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    December 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    January 2017
    November 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015

    © 2015-2022 Gabriel Neville

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Home
  • Blog
  • The Regiment
  • The Soldiers
  • Family
  • Living History
  • Learn More
  • Contact